Mystical Menu

Gourmet flavors guaranteed to inspire. Our naturally gluten-free flavors are infused with creativity and guaranteed to be beautiful, mouth-water works of art! A menu of our rotating cupcake flavors for Regular, Vegan, and Keto! We offer two types of frosting for our Regular cupcakes: buttercream and whipped cream cheese frosting. For all orders, you may pick one flavor per dozen cupcakes or per mini 2 dozen cupcakes. All cupcake flavors are cake flavors!

Daily Cupcakes

Don't see the flavor you're craving? Contact us to order your custom cupcakes! If you can dream it, we can concoct it! A forty-eight (48) hour advance notice required for custom orders.

Main ingredients for GF: Brown rice flour, milk, cornstarch, eggs, tapioca, xanthan gum, vanilla, and/or cocoa powder. Frosting base: Butter, cream cheese, cream, powdered sugar, vanilla, and/or cocoa powder.
Nostalgic Birthday

A vanilla cupcake with chocolate buttercream and sprinkles.
- Single
  $3.99
- Dozen
  $39.99
Tuxedo Birthday

A chocolate cupcake with vanilla buttercream and sprinkles.
- Single
  $3.99
- Dozen
  $39.99
Vanilla Birthday

A vanilla cupcake with vanilla buttercream and sprinkles.
- Single
  $3.99
- Dozen
  $39.99
Chocolate Birthday

A chocolate cupcake with chocolate buttercream and sprinkles.
- Single
  $3.99
- Dozen
  $39.99
Vanilla Diva

A vanilla cupcake with strawberry buttercream and sprinkles.
- Single
  $3.99
- Dozen
  $39.99
Chocolate Diva

A chocolate cupcake with strawberry buttercream and sprinkles.
- Single
  $3.99
- Dozen
  $39.99
Vanilla Salted Caramel

A vanilla cupcake with house-made salted caramel filling, our signature whipped cream cheese frosting, and a caramel drizzle.
- Single
  $3.99
- Dozen
  $39.99
Chocolate Salted Caramel

A chocolate cupcake with house-made salted caramel filling, our signature whipped cream cheese frosting, and a caramel drizzle.
- Single
  $3.99
- Dozen
  $39.99
Southern Red Velvet

A moist red velvet cake with our signature whipped cream cheese frosting.
- Single
  $3.99
- Dozen
  $39.99
Carrot Cake (Jan – Aug)

A moist and flavorful carrot cake cupcake with our signature whipped cream cheese frosting.
- Single
  $3.99
- Dozen
  $39.99
Pumpkin Spice (Sep – Dec)

A moist and flavorful pumpkin cupcake with seasonal spices, topped with our signature whipped cream cheese frosting, and a dusting of cinnamon sugar.

Top ↑
- Single
  $3.99
- Dozen
  $39.99
Tuesday Cupcakes
Snickerdoodle

A cinnamon vanilla cupcake, cinnamon vanilla buttercream, and topped with cinnamon sugar.
- Single
  $3.99
- Dozen
  $39.99
Grasshopper

A chocolate cupcake with mint whipped cream cheese frosting, chocolate ganache, and cookie crumbles on top.

Top ↑
- Single
  $3.99
- Dozen
  $39.99
Wednesday Cupcakes
Strawberry Cheesecake

A vanilla cupcake with cheesecake filling, whipped cream cheese frosting, and strawberry topping and graham crumbles.
- Single
  $3.99
- Dozen
  $39.99
Cookie Dough

A chocolate cupcake, cookie dough buttercream, and chocolate chips.

Top ↑
- Single
  $3.99
- Dozen
  $39.99
Thursday Cupcakes
Chocolate Raspberry Cheesecake

A chocolate cupcake cheesecake filling, chocolate whipped cream cheese frosting, mini chocolate chips, raspberry topping, and graham cracker crumbles on top.
- Single
  $3.99
- Dozen
  $39.99
Lemon Drop

A lemon cupcake, lemon buttercream, and yellow sugar crystals.

Top ↑
- Single
  $3.99
- Dozen
  $39.99
Friday Cupcakes
Cookies & Cream

A moist chocolate cupcake with frosting made from crushed-up chocolate sandwich cookies.
- Single
  $3.99
- Dozen
  $39.99
Maple Bacon

A maple bacon vanilla cupcake with maple whipped cream cheese frosting, garnished with bacon pieces.

Top ↑
- Single
  $3.99
- Dozen
  $39.99
Saturday Cupcakes
Lavender Lemon

A lemon cupcake with lemon curd filling, lavender whipped cream cheese frosting, and lavender buds on top.
- Single
  $3.99
- Dozen
  $39.99
Chocolate Sundae

A chocolate cupcake with vanilla buttercream frosting, chocolate ganache drizzle, sprinkles, a dollop of whipped cream cheese, and a cherry on top.

Top ↑
- Single
  $3.99
- Dozen
  $39.99
Vegan Cupcakes + More

Our Vegan cupcakes are Vegan & Gluten-Free and are available everyday at Olympia Baking Co. and by custom order.

Dairy-free, gluten-free, and vegan. Main ingredients: Brown rice flour, sugar, coconut milk, cornstarch, tapioca, xanthan gum, vanilla, and/or cocoa powder. Frosting base: Soy buttery spread, palm oil (ethically sourced), powdered sugar, vanilla, and/or cocoa powder.
Vegan Nostalgic

A vanilla cupcake with chocolate vegan buttercream.
- Single
  $4.29
- Dozen
  $42.99
Vegan Tuxedo

A chocolate cupcake with vanilla vegan buttercream.
- Single
  $4.29
- Dozen
  $42.99
Vegan Vanilla Vanilla

A vanilla cupcake with vanilla vegan buttercream.
- Single
  $4.29
- Dozen
  $42.99
Vegan Chocolate Chocolate

A chocolate cupcake with chocolate vegan buttercream.
- Single
  $4.29
- Dozen
  $42.99
Vanilla Salted Caramel

A vanilla cupcake, salted caramel filling, vanilla vegan buttercream, and salted caramel drizzle on top.
- Single
  $4.29
- Dozen
  $42.99
Vegan Chocolate Salted Caramel

A chocolate cupcake, salted caramel filling, vanilla vegan buttercream, and salted caramel drizzle on top.
- Single
  $4.29
- Dozen
  $42.99
Vegan Tuxedo Strawberry

A chocolate cupcake with strawberry filling, vanilla vegan buttercream, and a strawberry drizzle.
- Single
  $4.29
- Dozen
  $42.99
Vegan Vanilla Strawberry

A vanilla cupcake with strawberry filling, vanilla vegan buttercream, and a strawberry drizzle
- Single
  $4.29
- Dozen
  $42.99
Vegan Chocolate Strawberry

A chocolate cupcake with strawberry filling, chocolate frosting, and a strawberry drizzle.
- Single
  $4.29
- Dozen
  $42.99
Vegan Tuxedo Raspberry

A chocolate cupcake with raspberry filling, vanilla vegan buttercream, and a raspberry drizzle.
- Single
  $4.29
- Dozen
  $42.99
Vegan Vanilla Raspberry

A vanilla cupcake with raspberry filling, vanilla vegan buttercream, and a raspberry drizzle.
- Single
  $4.29
- Dozen
  $42.99
Vegan Chocolate Raspberry

A chocolate cupcake with raspberry filling, chocolate vegan buttercream, and a raspberry drizzle.
- Single
  $4.29
- Dozen
  $42.99
Vegan Vanilla Ganache

A vanilla cupcake with vanilla vegan buttercream and a chocolate drizzle.
- Single
  $4.29
- Dozen
  $42.99
Vegan Triple Chocolate

A chocolate cupcake with chocolate vegan buttercream and a chocolate drizzle.
- Single
  $4.29
- Dozen
  $42.99
Vegan Lavender Lemon

A lemon cupcake with lavender vegan buttercream and lavender buds.
- Single
  $4.29
- Dozen
  $42.99
Vegan Berry Lemonade

A lemon cupcake with a berry filling, lemon vegan buttercream, and a berry drizzle

Top ↑
- Single
  $4.29
- Dozen
  $42.99
Keto Cupcakes + Donuts

Grain-free, low-carb, and sugar-free! Diabetic friendly! Keto cupcakes are available at Olympia Baking Co. and by custom order.

Approximately 250-300 calories per cupcake with 3-4g carbs per cupcake. Keto vanilla main ingredients: Almond flour, coconut flour, eggs, butter, monk fruit, vanilla, sour cream. Keto chocolate main ingreidents: Almond flour, coconut oil, eggs, butter, monk fruit, coconut milk, vanilla, cocoa powder. Keto frosting base: Butter, cream, cream cheese, monk fruit, vanilla, and/or cocoa powder.
Keto Nostalgic

A vanilla cupcake with chocolate icing. Approx. 4g carbs per cupcake.
- Single
  $4.99
- Dozen
  $54.99
Keto Tuxedo

A chocolate cupcake with vanilla icing. Approx. 4g carbs per cupcake
- Single
  $4.99
- Dozen
  $54.99
Keto Vanilla Vanilla

A vanilla cupcake with vanilla icing. Approx. 4g carbs per cupcake.
- Single
  $4.99
- Dozen
  $54.99
Keto Chocolate Chocolate

A chocolate cupcake with chocolate icing. Approx. 3g carbs per cupcake.
- Single
  $4.99
- Dozen
  $54.99
Keto Coconut

A coconut cupcake with coconut icing. Approx. 4g carbs per cupcake.
- Single
  $4.99
- Dozen
  $54.99
Keto Lemon

A lemon cupcake with keto lemon icing. Approx. 4g carbs per cupcake.
- Single
  $4.99
- Dozen
  $54.99
Keto Cherry

A cherry cupcake with cherry icing. Approx. 4g carbs per cupcake.
- Single
  $4.99
- Dozen
  $54.99
Keto Donuts

A cinnamon or chocolate keto donut with vanilla or chocolate icing made up of coconut milk and monk fruit. Flavors may vary. Approx. 5g carbs per donut.
- Single
  $3.49
- Dozen
  $34.99